When you think of classic Robert Redford movies, your mind probably jumps to iconic films like Butch Cassidy and The Sundance Kid, The Sting, The Way We Were, All the President’s Men and The Natural. Redford also made some enjoyable movies that are likely just a little bit off your radar, such as the 1992 thriller Sneakers, co-starring Sidney Poitier. Another underrated film in Redford's oeuvre is the entertaining heist flick The Hot Rock (1972) directed by Peter Yates, (of Bullitt fame) and based on a novel by celebrated crime writer Donald E. Westlake. I re-visited the movie after Redford's recent passing, and it's an enjoyable, diverting movie that's worth checking out.
Redford plays John Dortmunder, a just-out-of-prison thief reluctantly pulled back into the game by his brother-in-law Andy for what appears to be a relatively low-risk, high-yield caper. The successful theft of a priceless diamond from a New York museum promises to deliver Dortmunder and his team a pretty decent payday. Of course, things quickly spiral out of control, and the museum heist is followed in short order by a prison break, an attack on a police station, and a clandestine visit to a bank, all in pursuit of the elusive diamond.
![]() |
| Robert Redford & George Segal |
Each attempt to acquire the diamond features clever (and increasingly absurd ) schemes conceived by Dortmunder, all of which spiral comically and chaotically out of control. Can Dortmunder and his motley crew of thieves find an idea that works, and finally steal the diamond? The Hot Rock is a breezy, witty caper film that showcases several 1970s New York locations via the excellent cinematography by Donald R. Brown, which is complemented by the jazzy score composed by the one and only Quincy Jones. The screenplay was written by William Goldman, who also penned the scripts for Butch Cassidy and The Sundance Kid and Marathon Man.
Redford is quietly effective as Dortmunder, subtly portraying the character's growing frustration with his failed plans, and his crew's inability to obtain the diamond. The film's stellar supporting cast, includes George Segal, Ron Liebman, Paul Sand and Zero Mostel, all do excellent work playing comic foils to Redford's low-key, but increasingly exasperated, straight man and master thief. The film has kind of an offbeat, deadpan sense of humor, and showcases a New York City that largely doesn't exist anymore via the excellent location shooting. The Hot Rock isn't trying to be a
high-stakes thriller or a slapstick comedy, but it finds a solid groove somewhere
in between, offering a charming Redford performance and an endearing rogue's gallery of supporting characters in an entertaining caper film.
Here's a look at the trailer for the film: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=48APEydOt64. Fun fact: George C. Scott played a thinly disguised version of Dortmunder, with the character renamed to Walter Upjohn Ballantine, in 1974's Bank Shot, directed by Gower Champion, which was also based on a Donald E. Westlake novel, the second in the "Dortmunder" series.


