Black Mouth: Nightmares From The Past Return

Ronald Malfi is one of the most talented writers currently working in horror fiction. He's penned atmospheric, eerie tales such as Come With Me, The Narrows and Bone White. Malfi has been compared to both Stephen King and Peter Straub, and those comparisons are not unwarranted. His work features well-drawn, emotionally driven characters who face powerful entities and otherworldly forces, but also battle demons of an internal and psychological nature. I've read several of his novels and short fiction collections, and enjoyed them all, but Black Mouth (2022), may just be my favorite.

In Black Mouth, Malfi crafts a haunting, character-driven tale that fuses supernatural dread with deeply human struggles. The novel centers on Jamie Warren, a man who's been trying to outrun his past, and overcome the memories of a haunted childhood. When he’s forced to return to his hometown after his mother's death,  he must face the childhood traumas he's long tried to bury. As Jamie reconnects with a group of friends he hasn't seen in years, he's drawn into a mystery tied to a sinister figure (known as The Magician) who once fascinated, tempted and terrified Jamie and his friends in their younger days.

Black Mouth isn’t just a ghost story or a supernatural thriller; it’s a powerful story about guilt, addiction, redemption, and the weight of memories. The horror aspects of the novel work because these people feel real to us. We can empathize with their pain, their fears, and their hopes. As the story shifts seamlessly between past and present, a horrifying truth is revealed about the being that shaped the lives of Jamie and his friends. In addition to the influences of King and Straub, there's also a strong echo of Ray Bradbury's Something Wicked This Way Comes in Malfi's lyrical prose, as part of the story revolves around a carnival hiding a sinister secret.

This thought-provoking and frightening story deftly mixes the psychological with the supernatural. The horror elements of the story are grounded in the emotional realities of Malfi's flawed, fully developed characters. There's also something of the epic sweep of novels like Straub's Ghost Story and Floating Dragon, as Black Mouth, the area of West Virginia that gives the novel its title, is itself decaying, and the darkness of the supernatural forces central to the story may be poisoning the land itself. Black Mouth is a slow-burning, atmospheric tale that lingers long after the final page. It's a compelling story about past events that haunt us, and what it takes to finally face them. If you haven't explored Ronald Malfi's work before, Black Mouth is a great place to start.